Background:

A positive safety culture is essential to patient safety. Validated assessment tools can identify areas for improvement and highlight differences between clinical settings. Few studies have assessed medical student perceptions of safety and none have identified how those perceptions may differ for particular clerkships. Students provide a unique perspective to learn about safety across different settings due to the nature of their rotating clinical experiences.

Methods:

We surveyed fourth year medical students (MS4s) at our academic institution using a modified version of the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) Hospital Survey on Patient Safety Culture. Selected questions were omitted or modified to target medical student experiences. Surveys were electronically distributed and collected via an online survey tool. Participants were randomized and responded to survey questions based on either their internal medicine (IM) or surgery clerkship experience. Corrected means were compared between the two groups using unpaired t–test.

Results:

121 of 170 MS4s (71.2%) completed the survey. Response rates from IM and surgery subgroups were similar [61(72%) and 60 (71%) respectively]. Table 1 summarizes MS4 safety perceptions by survey domain with supervisor actions to promote patient safety and physician–to–physician handoffs rated highest. Communication openness was the lowest rated. A notable 56% of MS4s reported they would not speak up when witnessing an event that may negatively affect patient care; 55% reported they were afraid to ask questions when things did not seem right. In comparing subgroups, MS4s reported a higher overall patient safety grade for the IM experience compared to surgery (4.01 vs 3.58; P–value <0.001). They also rated staffing, teamwork within units, organizational learning, and supervision of trainees higher during IM clerkships. Figure 1 illustrates the questions that received higher safety perceptions on IM clerkships. A notable exception was that MS4s perceived physician shift changes to be more problematic for IM patients compared to surgical ones (4.14 vs 4.51 P–value = 0.05).

Conclusions:

This safety culture assessment of medical students identified communication openness as a barrier to their engagement in patient safety. Students also note differences between their experiences on IM and Surgery clerkships, suggesting this assessment may be a useful source of information and feedback for clerkship directors and clinical service chiefs. Engaging students in safety education and awareness can leverage their capacity to participate in patient safety.

Table 1Perceptions of Safety Culture by Survey Domain

Figure 1Perceptions of Safety Culture: Internal Medicine versus Surgery.