Case Presentation:
A 34 year‐old male with hepatitis C and alcoholic liver cirrhosis presented with one day history of nausea, bilious vomiting and intermittent epigastric pain. The patient had elevated WBC but no fevers, SpO2 was 92% on ambient air, and abdomen was tender to palpation in the right upper quadrant. Intra‐abdominal processes were suspected, but abdominal ultrasound, HIDA scan, and paracentesis were all negative. Chest X ray revealed right pleural effusion and chest CT showed RLL infiltrate, so ceftriaxone and metronidazole were started for pneumonia with parapneumonic effusion. Thoracentesis showed an exudative fluid. Blood cultures detected Streptococcus pneumoniae but pleural fluid culture was negative. In the 48 hours after thoracentesis, he developed aggressive re‐accumulation of right pleural effusion and a chest tube was placed. Over the next two days nearly 4L of pleural fluid was drained from the chest tube, and repeat samples showed a transudative fluid, consistent with hepatic hydrothorax. Chest tube was clamped to prevent further nutritional and albumin loss, and aggressive diuretic treatment was begun. His hospital course was complicated by worsening cirrhosis and variceal bleeding, which required blood transfusions and 3 days in the MICU. On hospital day 16 the patient accidentally pulled out his chest tube and a fistula formed between the pleural space and the chest wall. Due to active alcohol use, the patient was not a candidate for liver transplantation, and he was discharged to hospice for comfort care on day 22.
Discussion:
Hepatic hydrothorax and spontaneous bacterial empyema (SBEM) are rare complications of cirrhosis. They have been known to occur even in the absence of ascites. SBEM occurs in 15% of hepatic hydrothorax patients. The diagnostic criteria include culture‐positive or culture‐negative pleural fluid, with PMN count greater than 500, or flank pus. At the time of chest tube placement this patient did not meet criteria for SBEM. Antibiotics were started before thoracentesis, however, which may have complicated the diagnosis. The presence of S. pneumoniae bacteremia in the setting of pleural effusion is supportive of the diagnosis of hepatic hydrothorax with SBEM. Placement of chest tubes is contraindicated in SBEM and hepatic hydrothorax. In this case, the clinical course included worsening cirrhosis and variceal bleeding, both of which are known complications of chest tube placement in hepatic hydrothorax. Chest tube placement might have accelerated the patient’s clinical course.
Conclusions:
Physicians should use caution when considering chest tubes in patients with cirrhosis. Even when imaging studies and pleural fluid suggest primary lung pathology, if the patient exhibits signs and symptoms of an intra‐abdominal process then chest tube should be deferred until hepatic hydrothorax can be definitively ruled out.